Site Meter Radical Avenue » Iraq

Iraq

Iraq Not Like Korea

Wednesday, April 9th, 2008

KoreaWhen the senior Senator from Arizona indicated that he would be comfortable with a 100 year US military presence in Iraq, he let slip a dirty little secret about the Bush-McCain vision for the Middle East. The neo-cons have been planning on establishing permanent US bases in Iraq all along. Welcome to Ft. Baghdad kid. Here we have no demilitarized zones.

South Koreans Friendly, Iraqis Hostile
In Korea, we sided with the friendly South Koreans against our mutual enemy, the North Koreans. Iraq is not divided in this manner. In Iraq, the enemy lurks around every corner. Our forces can’t retreat to the south because Hussein’s army was defeated 5 years ago.

Abrams_fallujah_1.JPGThe traditional war in Iraq ended in 2003. The insurgency began later that year, followed by a sectarian civil war. Now our soldiers are left to police the streets of neighborhoods where many residents continue to harbor an ill will towards them. Iraq has no population of citizens comparable to our allies, the South Koreans.

They’re Not Standing Up, We’re Not Standing Down
For years George Bush gave Americans optimistic reports about the new Iraqi military. Bush said as they stand up, we’ll stand down. But Iraqi troops are still deserting in the heat of battle, and militia groups are still active in places like Basra and Sadr City.

George Bush has no intention of even considering a withdrawal from Iraq. He will instead pass two wars on to his successor, having utterly failed to resolve either one.

Nation Building All Over Again
Iraq is George Bush’s Vietnam. The US Military patrols the villages in support of a weak and corrupt central government, while the citizens cling tightly to the words of their own local religious leaders.

, , ,

Trillion Dollar Debacle in Iraq

Thursday, March 20th, 2008

IraqWarHeader.jpgVice President Cheney had it right in 1994 when he predicted that toppling the Hussein government in Iraq would create a “quagmire”. Now, after five years of nation building, nearly 4,000 American soldiers dead and $500 billion spent, Mr. Cheney has declared the war in Iraq a “successful endeavor”. Of course this is the same guy who, on August 26, 2002, said this:

Simply stated, there is no doubt that Saddam Hussein now has weapons of mass destruction. There is no doubt he is amassing them to use against our friends, against our allies, and against us.

On that day Cheney was either incredibly misinformed or completely dishonest. In either case, he was wrong. America can’t afford to get it wrong when it comes to the reasons for invading another country, especially one that has never attacked us. Virtually anyone could have predicted all of the problems we’re now having in Iraq.

Hostile Towards Us
The historical animosity of Arabs toward western civilization goes all the way back to the Crusades. Today many people in that region disagree with our strong support of Israel, or the presence of US troops on what they consider their holy land. Some Iraqis benefited from Hussein’s rule, battled us in 1991 and are still fighting us now. Even with only 1% of the Iraqi population actively targeting Americans, in a country of 27 million, we’re up against a homegrown insurgent force of 270,000.

Hostile Towards Each Other
After decades of iron fisted rule by Saddam Hussein, many aggrieved Iraqis had old scores to settle. Tribal and spiritual leaders exert a strong influence in this part of the world. The religious and ethnic rivalries are well documented. Post Saddam sectarian strife was inevitable.

Hostile Neighborhood
Syria and Saudi Arabia support Sunnis living in western Iraq. Iran supports the majority Shiite. The Kurds of northern Iraq have stepped up their battle with the Turkey. At least we still have Kuwait on our side.

,

Iraq: Stay or Leave?

Tuesday, February 26th, 2008

Blackhawk_1.jpgWhen it comes to US Military involvement in Iraq, Republicans and Democrats offer sharply different visions for our future. Democrats want to begin withdrawing troops immediately and Republicans want to stay longer. John McCain even mentioned the possibility of a 100 year American commitment. Does a long term US military presence in a foreign country really make the world safer? The record is unclear.

Where We Stayed
Korea
We’ve had our troops stationed in Korea since the Truman administration. While this has allowed democratic South Korea to prosper, communist North Korea is as belligerent as ever.

Kosovo
About a week ago, the citizens of Kosovo declared their independence from Serbia. Now our soldiers must try to keep the peace among warring factions a decade after we first began providing security in the Balkan states.

Okinawa
Our Navy has been stationed in Japan since World War II. Sadly, the criminal acts of some soldiers reflect badly on our entire country. We may have worn out our welcome in Okinawa but there’s little chance of Japan attacking the US anytime soon.

Where We Left
Vietnam
The US has enjoyed relatively positive relations with Vietnam since we withdrew in the 1970s. In 2006, our two countries agreed to normalized trade relations. The socialist government of Vietnam has not invaded its neighbors or threatened the United States. And although Saigon is still known as Ho Chi Minh City, communism has not spread throughout Southeast Asia as we were warned of in the 1960s.

Somalia
Somalia has remained volatile since we left after the Black Hawk Down debacle in 1993. As a lawless country, it remains a haven for terrorists and other criminals, but the danger seems to be contained for now.

Lebanon
Fortunately our troops left Lebanon in the 1980s and are no longer directly engaged with the Palestinian militant groups there. Many Lebanese citizens live in relative comfort, but ongoing hostilities with Israel mean more clouds on the horizon.

, , , , ,

General Petraeus Grades Himself

Friday, September 21st, 2007

480px_David_H._Petraeus_1.jpg
I would have done much better in college if I had been able to grade myself. In fact I would have aced every test and graduated Magna Cum Laude. I may not have learned much though. If I had been able to grade myself, I would have spent even more time at the bars and even less time in the library.

It makes no sense to allow someone to grade their own performance. That’s why the breathlessly hyped testimony of General Petraeus before Congress was such a farce. General Petreaus has been tasked with making the military “surge” in Iraq work. What is he supposed to say: I’m doing a lousy job and need to be fired?

An independent evaluation of US progress in Iraq is of much greater value. Based on the recent GAO report to Congress, we’re not faring very well. But as usual, the mass media outlets aren’t looking for an impartial assessment of the situation. They’re looking for drama. They figured they would get more fireworks from the General’s testimony than they would from some unknown accountant citing verifiable facts and figures.

, , , ,

About Radical Avenue

If you want to find criticism of our government here in America, you won’t need to look far. When it comes to politics, it seems that everyone has a grievance. Radical Avenue on the other hand, takes a solutions oriented approach to public policy. It’s radical because I’m proposing fundamental changes to the structure of our government, like transferring commander in chief responsibilities to a small elected group. My philosophy is: Everyone knows we’ve got problems, so what are we going to do about it?

Radical Avenue Author(s)
    » Bob-Betzen

Blogging Flair

Politics & News Channel Posts

  • Friday Six -- Olympic Controversy Edition
    More than handi-capable... The great thing about sports is, except for the draft which rewards franchises that finish last, it is largely free from a lot of the egalitarian bull-crap that [...]
  • Shifting Political Landscape in China
    According to reports from devastated Sichuan province, the Chinese government has devoted substantial resources to ongoing earthquake rescue and recovery efforts. China's emergency response now [...]
  • Take My Advice
    Better listen to him...he's pre-med. I think the hardest thing about being an advice columnist would be that whole part where you have to stop laughing long enough to write the column. [...]
  • John McCain Looks To Appeal To Younger Voters
    "Yo, dude, let me rap with you about social security..." - This report is the first in a series of articles about the upcoming hysterical historical Presidential election... - Republican [...]
  • Obama draws diverse crowd of eager volunteers
    This past Saturday I attended a voter registration drive hosted by Barack Obama's campaign. At 10am the office was packed, with volunteers pouring out the front door. They had to announce [...]
  • Why Hillary won't drop out....just yet (Al Gore to the rescue?)
    Why won't she just drop out? There are a number of reasons why Hillary won't just drop out of the race. Let's explore a few of them. First of all, and this is one nobody is talking [...]
  • Burma and the UN
    An angry cyclone pounded Burma last week and left a bitter cloud of despair in its wake. As entire villages now battle to survive, thousands of aid workers sit just over the borders waiting for the [...]
  • McSame's Disastrous Economic Policies
    Don't look now, but the Straight Talk Express has derailed again. Lately, the senior Senator from Arizona has been serving up enough whoppers to make the Burger King proud. Surely by now someone [...]
  • Civil Unions Inevitable Despite Backward Adherence to Religious Interpretation
    An intersection of personal reading and casual conversation this weekend led me to think again about the issue of gay marriage. I read an article in this weekend’s New York Times Magazine [...]
  • World Food Crisis Originating from Multiple Sources
    Everyone who has stayed up late to watch bad movies and old TV shows is familiar with ads from non-profit groups soliciting funds to feed the poor. These commercials use heart-rending images of [...]

Hot Off The Press

  • Last day, to drop a Session I course wit...
    To drop a Session I course without the drop appearing on the permanent record or counting toward the limit of dropped courses. [...]
  • David Boreanaz bloopers
    In honor of David's birthday, I thought I'd share a blooper reel that as Boreanaz fans you should enjoy. Sure, it's bloopers of Angel, but hey, Boreanaz is Boreanaz. And besides, it's hilarious! I [...]
  • When the World gets so STRESSED: Find an alibi
    New Photo by Mary MacIntyre What a day, and a long one! I took a break and had lunch with a friend at Tecolote on Cerrillos. It hit the spot. Perfect for a cold rainy day. Day 2 of rain a [...]
  • Panasonic Gets It Right The Second Time Around
    Panasonic DMP-BD30 - sleek, compact, and snappy! One of the problems of almost all ( well, every one I saw) of the first generation Blu-ray players was the excruciatingly long start time from disc [...]
  • Official Smackdown Preview: Chasing the title
    Although SmackDown General Manager Vickie Guerrero stripped Undertaker of the World Heavyweight Championship, The Deadman has the opportunity to regain the gold in a title match with Edge at [...]
  • The View Schedule May 19-23
    Here is The View schedule for May 19-23. I wonder what the "special announcement" is that they are going to make on Monday? MONDAY, MAY 19 – A “Day of Hot Topics”; the co-hosts interview [...]
  • Dana On Leno!
    Hello, again! Well, apparently technology doesn’t like me too much because The View didn’t tape. I’ll still be recapping Teri’s appearance tonight, though. For now? Let’s talk Dana [...]
  • Green your Own Lawn Naturally, Here's How:
    1. Pick the right kind of grass for your own area: Having grass that's adapted to your own climate area will be a natural grass and end up being less work for you or your lawn maintenance person in [...]
  • What's HAPPENING in my neighborhood ...
    the PEE DEE and the GRAND STRAND. The summer is definitely coming. The attractions and cool stuff is getting ready for Memorial Day, for sure. The Bikers on Harley Davidson's are enjoying [...]
  • Foley News, Kerry Wood on McMahons' Theme
    -MicK Foley comments on the CW 11.com on him going to be a Smackdown Commentator. Check it out.... -Apparently someone somewhere suggested that Chicago Cubs closer Kerry Wood should use the [...]