Site Meter Radical Avenue » Blog Archive » Historians Weigh In

Historians Weigh In

by Bob Betzen

The aftermath of Vietnam left many scholars with afterthoughts about war and peace in America. Senator Jacob Javits wrote ““Declaring war… is only one part of the Congress’s constitutionally assigned war power. Article 1, Section 8 also instructs Congress to provide for the common defense, to raise and support armies and navies, make rules for the government and regulation of the armed forces and organize and govern militia. When combined with the ‘necessary and proper’ clause, Article 1, Section 8 offers overwhelming evidence that Congress is required by the Constitution to determine whether the United States makes war or remains at peace.

“. . . It is . . . one of the terrible ironies of American history that as war has become more destructive, less humane and less controllable, the power of decision over war has become increasingly concentrated in the hands of one American. This trend of history carries with it a portent of death for millions of human beings in the nuclear age. The American people can reverse this trend by insisting on the reinstatement of representative deliberations over the fearful decision as to war and peace.”

Historian Arthur Schlesinger intoned: “The Founders were determined to deny the American President what Blackstone had assigned to the British King – ‘the sole prerogative of making war and peace.’

“The resistance to giving a ‘single man,’ even if he were President of the United States, the unilateral authority to decide on war pervaded the contemporaneous literature. . . .

“There is no evidence that anyone supposed that his office as Commander in Chief endowed the President with an independent source of authority. . . . The President had no more authority than the first general of the army or the first admiral of the navy would have as professional military men. The President’s power as Commander in Chief, in short, was simply the power to issue orders to the armed forces within a framework established by Congress.”

Louis Fisher has written extensively about Constitutional separation of powers. “President Harry Truman went to war against North Korea in 1950 without asking Congress for authority. Since that time, presidents regularly have used military force by relying on what they regard as independent and self-sufficient sources of authority, especially the commander-in-chief clause. These assertions of political power have no legal foundation…..

“The constitutional balance of power between Congress and the president has not been altered by the UN Charter, mutual security treaties, the threat of nuclear war or other developments of the period since World War II.

“It is hackneyed to argue that contemporary conditions make it necessary to vest in the president the decision to go to war. If the national security risk is great, so is the risk of presidential miscalculation and aggrandizement — all the more reason for insisting military decisions be thoroughly examined and approved by Congress. Contemporary presidential judgments need more, not less scrutiny.”

Not everyone in Congress signed on to the hand wringing “necessary and appropriate” resolution of 2002. Senator Robert Byrd made his objections clear. “Before risking the lives of American troops, all members of Congress … must overcome the siren song of political polls and focus strictly on the merits, not the politics, of this most serious issue.

The resolution before us today is not only a product of haste; it is also a product of presidential hubris. This resolution is breathtaking in its scope. It redefines the nature of defense, and reinterprets the Constitution to suit the will of the Executive Branch. It would give the President blanket authority to launch a unilateral preemptive attack on a sovereign nation that is perceived to be a threat to the United States. This is an unprecedented and unfounded interpretation of the President’s authority under the Constitution…”

,


Leave a Reply


About Radical Avenue

If you want to find criticism of our government here in America, you won’t need to look far. When it comes to politics, it seems that everyone has a grievance. Radical Avenue on the other hand, takes a solutions oriented approach to public policy. It’s radical because I’m proposing fundamental changes to the structure of our government, like transferring commander in chief responsibilities to a small elected group. My philosophy is: Everyone knows we’ve got problems, so what are we going to do about it?

Radical Avenue Author(s)
    » Bob-Betzen

Blogging Flair

Politics & News Channel Posts

  • Tougher Homes Needed in California
    Good news. Here in California, the Building Standards Commission has adopted new residential construction codes intended to cut water usage and increase energy efficiency in new homes. The [...]
  • Cowboy Junkies
    "Okay, okay ... I'll have chicken again tonight..." I thought I missed something. The headline on the story read: "Bull Riding Is Becoming Mainstream." Really? If you've been to a bull [...]
  • Mass Transit Popular Again
    Peer down from the ninety ninth floor of an urban skyscraper and commuters look like little bugs. Every day thousands of worker bees cram into giant steel buildings to produce a little honey for [...]
  • Bush = (Wilson + Hoover) * Buchanan
    Mathematically inclined historians may calculate for decades before finding the right equation to fully assess the Bush presidency. While measuring the gap between the federal budget surplus Bush [...]
  • One More Silver Dollar
    If you can read this you're too close ... and legally blind Government officials announced today that the U.S. Mint will soon produce a new silver dollar commemorating the birth of Louis Braille [...]
  • Democracy No Panacea
    American politicians like to promote democracy as a polished gemstone behind a plate glass window at the jewelry store, rather than as a diamond in the rough still encrusted in stone. A country's [...]
  • George Carlin Dies
    - Fuck. - George Carlin, 1937-2008 - [...]
  • Diplomatic Circles
    Even the dark cloud over US foreign policy left behind by the Bush administration has a silver lining. Other countries now know that they can't count on America for political leadership, so they've [...]
  • I, Love Robot
    Sexy...in a Power Rangers kind of way... Not content with dominating the world auto market, the Japanese robotic industry is now working to make American women smaller, quieter and more fuel [...]
  • Gloomy Guantanamo Bay
    King Henry VIII had the Tower of London. Nikita Khrushchev had the Gulags of Siberia. Guantanamo Bay seems to be George Bush's barbaric detention center of choice. During previous conflicts, [...]

Hot Off The Press

  • Coco Sumner does her dad proud
    Performing before a large crowd at a charity benefit, Coco Sumner, only 17 years old, is sure making her daddy proud. This young chick's dad only happens to be none other than the legendary Sting, [...]
  • Words of Wisdom from Nina Garcia
    Women of the world, I beg of you, take to heart this statement made by Nina Garcia as she judged this week's Project Runway designs: "I think shiny, tight and short is the quickest way to look [...]
  • Booking Through Thursday - First Lines
    Hello everyone and happy Thursday. Welcome again to yet another slightly late Booking Through Thursday. I reckon I should just start calling it “Booking Through Thursday Afternoon” or “Booking [...]
  • Sherri Shepherd Discusses Precious Times Article (video)
    Here is a video clip of The View on Wednesday July 23 where Sherri Shepherd sought to clarify comments that she made in an interview with Precious Times about her prior history of abortions and [...]
  • The Birth of Religion - Part 13
    by Seeker Some of the new knowledge we have come to from science tells us that the Earth is in flux. The surface of the planet is still recovering from the Ice Age, both in climate and in physical [...]
  • Ways to Cook a Good Pepper
    Peppers have been used in many dishes since the beginning of man kind on plant earth. The Indians used peppers of all varieties in their medicine practices as well. Peppers continue to be a staple [...]
  • Build an Awesome Burger
    Four of the best hamburgers can be made in your own kitchen or backyard tonight for dinner. Here's how their made. • Big Kahuna Burger 10 oz. ground turkey, divided into two patties 4 [...]
  • News of the Who
    John and his sister Carole in SoCal for a book signing. The fabulous TVShowsOnDVD.com is reporting that the US series one Torchwood Blue-ray DVD set release has been pushed back to 11 November. [...]
  • The View Schedule July 28-August 1st
    Here is the guest line-up for The View for July 28th-August 1st, which will be the last week before the show's month-long hiatus. I really hope that the hosts learned from their last experience with [...]
  • If everybody was like me, the world would be perfect!
    Bet that title grabbed your eye! But isn't that the way we all feel? If our families would just listen to us, do what we say/recommend/order, then life would be so much easier! At work, [...]